We install both artificial turf and natural sod, so we do not have a reason to push one over the other. The right answer depends on how you use the yard, how much sun it gets, and how much time and water you want to spend on it.
Artificial turf costs more up front but needs no watering, no mowing, and no fertilizer. It stays green through August. Good turf installs come down to the base: old lawn removed, ground graded to drain, and a compacted rock base so the turf stays flat. Pet owners should ask for turf with a drainage backing and a pet-friendly infill.
Natural sod costs less to install and stays noticeably cooler on a hot afternoon. Turf in full sun can get hot to the touch. Sod also gives you real soil that absorbs rain. The trade-off is water, mowing, and a sprinkler system that actually covers the whole lawn.
A common middle ground is turf where the kids and dogs play in full sun, and sod or planting beds where you want it cooler and greener. Either way, the prep under the lawn decides how it looks in two years.
